Canadian Investor@canadianinvestor · 8mo
I agree with you that most people should probably not use margin.
That said a couple of points. With a margin loan you are not required to make a monthly payment the value of the loan increases by the amount of interest. Interest on top of interest can occur more risk.
The other thing to fully understand is margin maintainence requirement.
A margin call may not wipe out your account it could be you having to add a small amount of money.
While I don't disagree with the premise I think it works better to be factual vs fear based.
If you borrow to buy an S&P 500 index with a 30% margin requirement and you put in $30,000 while borrowing $70,000, you now control $100,000.
If the market drops 50%, your portfolio falls to $50,000, but the loan is still $70,000. You are now negative $20,000.
To meet the 30% margin requirement, you would need $15,000 in equity, which means you would have to deposit $35,000 just to stay in the position. That’s more than your original investment.
This is the risk of fully using your margin.
Now compare that to a more conservative approach. If you invest $80,000 and borrow $20,000, you still have $100,000 invested. If the market drops 50%, your portfolio is worth $50,000 and your loan is $20,000, leaving you with $30,000 in equity.
You are still well above the required margin. No margin call would happen.
Margin calls are often misunderstood and create a lot of fear over what they are and they are handled differently at different brokers. Some give you a notification to make a depost or sell others liquidate immediately. You should know how your broker handles margin calls before you use it and fully understand margin requirements and maintainence.
Also understand that brokers can change the margin maintainence on a fund at any time so when you originally invested it might have been 30% but that can change to 50% 70% 100%