Retiring Early? The Order of Market Returns Matter
In Episode 29 of Financial KarMoe @karyungtom and I kick things off with a little hockey talk, including how the Edmonton Oilers, Montreal Canadiens and Vancouver Canucks have been doing so far this season, before diving into two important topics for Canadian investors. 🏒📈 We take a closer look at BMO's new $ZALL ETF (BMO MSCI All Country World Index ETF). What makes this fund different from the traditional all-in-one ETFs like $XEQT? We discuss global market-cap weighting, Canadian home-country bias, the fund's significant US exposure, and whether having a portfolio that reflects the actual size of global stock markets makes sense. We also touch on why some investors have been looking for a simpler way to get globally diversified equity exposure without having to manage multiple ETFs. Next, we get into something particularly important for anyone thinking about financial independence or early retirement: sequence of returns risk. What happens if the stock market delivers its worst returns during the first few years of your retirement? Can two investors earn the exact same average annual return but end up with dramatically different retirement outcomes simply because the order of those returns is different? Kar walks us through some fascinating retirement simulations using his calculator, including scenarios where a $1 million portfolio with a $40,000 annual withdrawal can run out of money in one sequence but continue growing in another. We discuss withdrawal rates, the 4% rule, cash wedges, dynamic withdrawals and whether keeping money outside the market is worth the potential opportunity cost. We also explore how pensions, CPP, alternative income sources and adjusting discretionary spending can help manage retirement risk. And importantly, we discuss why planning for early retirement isn't just about reaching a portfolio number. It's also about understanding what you're retiring to, what you might be giving up, and whether your retirement lifestyle is actually what you envision. We wrap up with a discussion about return of capital (ROC), how it affects adjusted cost base (ACB) in non-registered accounts, and why understanding the tax treatment matters. As always, we appreciate your questions and comments on YouTube and Blossom. We hope you enjoy the discussion! Question for you: If you were retiring tomorrow, would you keep 1-2 years of expenses in cash to protect against a market downturn, or would you prefer to stay fully invested and adjust your withdrawals when needed? Let us know in the comments! 👇 Thanks for watching and supporting Financial KarMoe! 🙏🏼 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MF9X7KiKeKE
778 views
9 Comments
Catherine
@ffcatherine · 1h
Great episode as always! Sequence of returns risk depends greatful on several factors: 1 -overall size of portfolio vs basic living expenses needed ( this doesn’t include fun or discretionary spend do it usually cannot be reduced) 2- “gap # yrs” how much expenses must your portfolio cover BEFORE any fixed income arrives 3- “your peace of mind number”- this number is not the optimal return per dollar but how confident are you that you’re covered during a bad bear market Etc
You should promote a “cash wedge “ as I personally do for retirement and as KAR mentioned, when you get to point of X portfolio size it’s less concerning of what could I possibly make if you invested in an asset. It truly is for peace of mind. I personally hold $103,000 or 5% of my portfolio but where do you hold the cash wedge? It’s in my LIF and RRIF accounts for mandatory withdrawals. The gap ? The gap is your retirement age until you start your fixed income payments from the government in the form of CPP and OAS. You will adjust your withdrawal rate accordingly or adjust your OAS start date based on a clawback scenario. Let’s just call it what it is and Bengens revised withdrawal rate of 4.7% not 4% I always see withdrawals as dynamic not static although I’m personally trying to melt down my own RRSP (RRIF) I can use the cash wedge during a bear market if I find my income is greatly reduced or purchase more shares when the stock market is on sale and reload after a recovery. Great episode and discussions that need to happen before retirement. Ps. Have something to retire to not away from!
Mike L
@noviceadvisor · 1h
Great, now you jinxed them 🤣
See the full comment section 👀Sign up for the full Blossom experience!