A little backstory. The 4% rule was introduced by financial planner Bill Bengen back in 1994. The idea is that you can withdraw 4% of your investment portfolio in your first year of retirement, then increase that dollar amount every year to keep up with inflation. But in 2025, Bengen revisited his research and found that with a more diversified portfolio, the historical starting withdrawal rate could actually be closer to 4.7%. So what does that mean for your FIRE number? Let's say you spend $40K a year. Using the traditional 4% rule, you'd need $1 million invested. Using 4.7%, you'd need approximately $851K. That's almost $150K less. Which is a pretty big difference! BUT before you start lowering your retirement goals, there's something important to consider. This research looks at historical US market data over a 30 year retirement. If you're planning to retire in your 30s or 40s, your money could need to last 40, 50 or even 60 years. And yes, inflation is still accounted for. You're just starting with a higher withdrawal amount and increasing that dollar amount with inflation each year. Personally, I think this is a really interesting reminder that the 4% rule isn't necessarily a one size fits all approach. So I'm curious, would you feel comfortable using 4.7% to calculate your FIRE number, or are you sticking with the traditional 4%?
418 views
9 Comments
Phil @diversifiedfill · 3h
It's only a guideline for calculation purposes. In Canada, the CRA forces you to withdraw a minimum from your RRIF anyways, which will generally be MORE than 4%. No choice when you hit the year you turn 71. It's calculated by CRA at 1 / (90 - age). But CIBC has a handy dandy sheet here: https://www.woodgundy.cibc.com/en/reference/retirement-planning/rrif-minimum-withdrawal.html
Clifster @clifster · 2h
Never use that or any rule. When retired Covered Call ETF's take care of everything!!
Matt @griff79 · 3h
Perhaps closer to the traditional 4% knowing the research supports a bit of a buffer.
Clifster @clifster · 1h
@diversifiedfill no I cant because my RRIF came from my company pension that is a registered account and has specific % for min and max depending on one's age
See the full comment section 👀Sign up for the full Blossom experience!